MJ’s Idol Pool Week 9 Update

Congrats to Week 9 winners:

1 ChrisP13
2 elsinore
2 jodi21
2 nika
2 oreos10
2 tkbowersox
7 sav129

And the Top 3 overall are:

1 bugsy
2 maracaibo
2 WSULeifJ

Congrats and good luck tonight! Remember, first prize is an iTunes gift card!

Who do I think will leave this week? I have no clue. The only contestants who I feel really confident are safe are David Archuleta and David CookSyesha Mercado had a strong performance, and postive comments from the judges, but she went first this week. Still, I think there’s a good chance she’ll be safe.  Carly Smithson performed second to last and got excellent comments from the judges, including Simon.  But, perhaps people felt it was safe not to vote for her this week, and she could be a surprise boot. Despite a weak performance, performing early in the lineup and negative critiques from the judges,  Jason Castro may still be safe this week.  Randy and Simon’s unusually harsh criticism may have created a backlash–even casual voters may have thrown a few pity votes Jason’s way.  His fan base was certainly kicked into high gear. Maybe Jason will live to see another week.  Brooke White broke down completely.  She hasn’t had a good performance in weeks.  It’s really her time to go.  But, between her vulnerability, and Simon and Randy sticking up for her, she could squeak by.

What to do?  I think Brooke should leave She gets all my points in this week’s pool.


Related Posts

MJS Idol Pool Week 14 Update - Finale and Winners!
MJ’S Idol Pool - Week 5 Update
MJ’S Idol Pool Update
So You Think You Can Dance - Pool
MJ’s Idol Pool - Top 20 Standings

54 Responses to “MJ's Idol Pool Week 9 Update”


Pages: « 1 [2] Show All

  1. 51 CJ Apr 23rd, 2008 at 8:47 pm

    I live in Az and my kids and I called on two phones - both - numbers and due to the busy tones got thru about 10 times only - oh - for Jason

    I live in OH, and if I try to vote on my landline I can’t get through at all (I’m in Cooktardsville, OH, BTW :smile1_tb:), but I can get though with very, very few busy signals on my cell phone (two I think? Calling, not texting…) I think the carrier is the difference.

    I am nervous, too…I may be a Cooktard, but I like Jason and I don’t want to see him go yet. Brooke definitely deserves that more, IMO.

  2. 52 GeminiDolly Apr 23rd, 2008 at 8:50 pm

    I at least wanted Jason Top 4, but he just really sukked it hard last night. It was worse than KLCs 8 days a week and probably one of the worst in Idol history. What was up with him breathing so hard into the mic? I hope someone advises him to fix that. I still adore him and will buy his music but Its not a shocker that hes going home. Its a shame it got leaked though.

  3. 53 sumidol Apr 23rd, 2008 at 9:20 pm

    CJ - I like Cook too - each for a different mood - I hope they both go thru to the end and G-Dolly NOTHING can EVER be worse than how Kristy country - fried that Beatle song - nothing I dont think?

  4. 54 sumidol Apr 23rd, 2008 at 9:21 pm

    Oh Dolly, Jason had a temp of 104 and had an IV in him before he went out but said nothing. Neither did the judges like they did for Rami and Kristy when THEY were sick HMMMM???

Pages: « 1 [2] Show All

Leave a Reply

You must login to post a comment.




Apple iTunes
July 2008
S M T W T F S
« Jun    
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031