newbie389′ American Idol Tour Cleveland Re-Cap

So, a little info on me. Girl, 17, this was my fourth idol concert (been going since season 5) and I’ve absolutely loved them all. Went to the Cleveland show for seasons 5 & 6, Columbus last year, and now Cleveland again (I only live about 20 minutes from the arena). I went with my parents, as is the tradition. My mom watches idol with me and we usually have similar opinions. Sometimes my dad watches with us too, but he didn’t see much of this season. It was fun to describe every idol beforehand so he’d at least have a clue who they were J Matt was my favorite this season, and after he was gone I voted for Kris. I had my opinions about everyone, but usually that starts to fall away for me when the concert rolls around. So I was stoked to see all of them and give them all a fair shot.

I’ll try not to re-hash too much of what had already been said, but I guess that’s inevitable! I’ll do my best with this, I’m not the best writer haha. Skip around, I’m sorry it’s so long! & I hope I didn’t make too many errors lol.

We got to the arena around 6 after finding a lot to park in and walking over. For anyone who cares, my outfit was my favorite green tank top, a black cotton vest, white&gray striped shorts and gray flip flops. Our seats weren’t bad- lower level, fifth row, kinda far back but I loved the view of the stage. Once we found our seats, I went to wait in line for merch- got the black tee and a tour book as usual. Hit up the concessions to get a bottle of Gatorade, since I was getting my wisdom teeth out the next day and couldn’t eat or drink anything past 10 pm. So then I got in line for the bathroom since I had time to spare. Lines weren’t bad at this time, but I must say it didn’t help that there were two separate entrances, both with lines. And also, there were more urinals than toilets in this women’s bathroom. Not even kidding! I counted while in line haha, 12 urinals. I’ve been to the Wolstein Center a few times, but I’ve never encountered that bathroom. Maybe they planned on it being divided, I’m not sure, but they should do something about that lol, because it’s just a waste. It was funny, people walked in like ‘umm this is the women’s bathroom..?’ , lots of clueless looks and laughing lol. But anyways, on with the show!

Got back in time to see more Carrie Underwood vids..no offense, but couldn’t they mix it up a bit more? I did the texting contest but didn’t win. One of the ladies behind me was a huge Adam fan and she asked about the program I bought, so I let her look through it while we were waiting and we all talked about idol stuff, it’s fun to meet people there! Then it was time for the show!

Michael’s opening was a fun way to get the crowd going. And he just seems like such a nice, average guy, you know? He talked a bit which I liked. He was like, ‘just stand up, and if a person behind you tells you to sit down, tell them to stand up! Seriously!’  haha. I did feel the band overpowered him a bit, especially on the first song, but it added a lot of energy. It was interesting to hear him sing R&B, I still think he’s got such a country voice’ ¦but for me, it worked!

Megan was next, and her background screens made me laugh. Distracting, I suppose, but I actually how they helped tell the story especially in the second song. There were cute haha. The colorful trees and question marks and such. As for Megan herself, I liked her more than I thought I would. I didn’t think her singing was that bad, the set was kinda fun. And she did totally look like a Barbie. Oh, and her hair was straight for this show.

Scott rose up on the piano and my first impression was that I liked his hair better now than on the show. Her first song was nice, but to me it seemed kinda long or drawn out or something. I but I didn’t hear any pitch problems. 1000 miles just isn’t my favorite song, but I think he pulled it off. Overall I didn’t find him as memorable as others, but at least he wasn’t memorable in a bad way either! Cool guy & I like that he interacted with the audience.

Lil wasn’t wearing a trench coat at this show. Or maybe she stopped that a long time ago and I haven’t been keeping up lol. My mom didn’t like her hair long, but I was indifferent. Single Ladies was fun and got people dancing. I think she’s got a powerful voice, but I still feel like something’s missing from her. I think it’s because I don’t feel the same uniqueness from her as some of the others. She’s still talented, I just don’t quite see her having a successful recording career. Maybe she could be on Broadway or something, though.

Anoop has changed my mind completely on this tour! On the show, I agreed with Simon on the ‘yo-yo’  comment- that he had good weeks and bad weeks and couldn’t exactly find the right place to define himself. I think I also kinda didn’t like him because I wished someone else would have made the top 13 over him. But wow, I loved him at the concert. I thought he made good song choices and was voice was gorgeous, especially on Always On My Mind. Mad had a nice vibe for him and I just like the song. I did like My Prerogative on the show, but I absolutely loved it in this concert setting. Fun & lots of energy. He’s one good looking guy which I don’t think I ever noticed before. The lady behind me said to her daughter something like, ‘he could totally be standing outside Abercrombie and Fitch’  and her daughter- my age- was like ‘uh, he could totally be my husband!’  Haha i agree. Anyway, I’d buy his album. He impressed me.

Matt was my favorite on the show, I was voting for him, so I’m biased. Just a head’s up. The intro was cool and I loved his energetic beginning. And it was awesome to see the crowd’s enthusiasm, he really brought it. A lot of times on the show you could hear his nerves, but he brought the confidence here as well. Loved the piano playing, he rocked it out. Georgia was a good reminder of his performance in Hollywood, and a nice showing of who he is, since he used to play at a piano bar. And You Found Me is a song I really like, so I enjoyed it. Love to see the fedora haha. I think it was a good choice to do a current song. Overall, I think he showed what he’s got, and he’s really come into his own since the show. Can’t wait for his album! But I’ll move on now.

Group number was fun. Loved the guys in suits and all. The rapping was cool, different. Loved the Billy Joel on the piano. I think the whole thing was a nice way to combine them all, briefly, while showcasing everyone. Just my personal opinion, but I like the concert set-up of seeing them more separately than together. I think it’s important because it allows them to transition from the show to their career, and really show people who they are.

Intermission: I went to the bathroom first, hoping to beat the line. And I didn’t do too bad. The lines were crazy as a walked out. It would have been so much better if not for the whole urinals-in-the-women’s-bathroom thing haha. Then I went back, watched a couple of those music videos, got ready for the second half. My parents both enjoyed the first half- my dad was impressed that he actually liked it lol. My mom and I are usually on the same page, so she was having a lot of fun too.

Allison’s a powerhouse; I can’t believe she’s younger than me! So What was young and current which I liked for her. Barracuda- the guitar player was great and Cry Baby- she really showed off her strong voice. I’m interested to hear her music in the future to see what she does.

Danny wasn’t my favorite on the show, although I did really like his voice on some performances. I love PYT and Michael Jackson songs in general, so I was glad he did it. It brought the energy and got people up and dancing. Maria Maria was a nice vibe, different. I know I wanted to do Latin on the show, so I’m glad he got to do it now. Dancing with the boots was kinda awkward I suppose, but I enjoyed his voice- pleasant but strong at the same time. I didn’t mind the ’speech’ , not very long-winded. I’m not into country music, but those are two songs I like and I think they were good choices for him.

But honestly, everyone at this point was thinking about, waiting for, anticipating, and freaking out about Adam. Kinda myself included, not gonna lie lol. I’ll premise this by saying that I wasn’t really a huge Adam fan or anything on the show. I knew he was really talented, just not my cup of tea. I preferred others, but I knew I’d always wish him the best. However, I found myself really anxious for him to come out. You could feel the intensity and excitement in the arena, really crazy actually. People were getting out of their seats (finally, lol), going ‘omg is he coming’ , and all that stuff. The build-up was insane, and when he finally came out, the crowd erupted and everyone stood up to be able to see him when he came on. Lighting for WLL was awesome. Adam’s vocals are incredible, he’s so talented. I found myself wondering how it was possible that he had to be on American Idol, but I guess he just needed the right chance. Loved his voice on Starlight, Mad World was beautiful, haunting, nice to see a softer side. The duet w. Allison was great of course, they’re good together. And I loved the David Bowie medley. Seriously, he is just so talented, I don’t know what else to say. He impressed me big time, I’m so glad I was there to see him. Before the show, when I was talking to the lady sitting behind me, she said she knew it was gonna be one of those things that you can look back on and say ‘yeah, I was there..’  or whatever. That’d be awesome, I hope so, I wish him the best.

I didn’t know how Kris was going to follow the intensity of Adam, but for me, he did for sure. I loved the set up for Heartless, simple yet cool’ ¦just like Kris. I think ATTTID was a good choice, even though I was skeptical at first, it got the crowd into it. Ain’t No Sunshine was a favorite of mine on the show and I was a good chance to see him at the piano. Bright Lights was my favorite- so much energy, he brought intensity to it and I thought it was great. You can see that Kris really feels the music, and I love that. And I really feel his set and song choices did a good job defining him and showing what he’s got. Hey Jude was a nice closing with all the idols. Can’t wait to see what Kris does in the future.

Don’t Stop Believing was a perfect way to end the show, all of them together again, the pianos, and Kris and Adam coming on together.

So yeah, I loved the show, haha. No complaints really, I liked the production. I thought the sound was a bit loud, though. At times it seemed that I couldn’t fully enjoy their voices because it was turned up so loud, and we were sitting pretty far back too, but maybe that was just me, I dunno. My dad immediately said it was the best one of the four seasons we’ve seen, and my mom and I agreed. He also commented on how much more ‘edgy’  it was than in past seasons, and he meant it in a good way, so he enjoyed the show way more than he thought he would, and thought that everyone was decent this year. Usually he’ll leave during someone’s set to ‘buy me program’  or something haha, he’ll think up some excuse to leave, we make a big joke every year about who he’s going to miss to buy a program, but he stayed for everyone and liked it. My mom absolutely loved the whole thing and so did I, she also commented on how much she liked the set-up and the screens for backgrounds because it was different from past seasons.

I wish them all the best with whatever they do. After the show, I definitely feel that Adam and Kris are deserving of the top two spots, but I enjoyed the whole show and think there’s a lot of talent. I love the tour because I always like them all better live. It was an incredible show that I’ll never forget and I’m so happy I got to go! Can’t wait to see where their careers take them. It’d be cool to see them in town on their own solo tours soon. If you have to a chance to go see this show, it is so worth it!!

24 Responses to “newbie389′ American Idol Tour Cleveland Re-Cap”


  • Just curious, who was your favorite in Season 5?

  • Thanks for the recap. I enjoyed your writing style, so it was a lot of fun to read . Thanks for taking the time to type it up.The uninal thing in the women’s bathroom was wierd, huh? And yes, it is a significant memory of the first time seeing Adam perform live in concert. I was wondering what your father thought of that :) The kids all did just fine and are working so hard on tour. At the end of season tour, they will all do well in their own ways and these will be the memories that will be their strongest.I wish them all the best.

  • Nice, fun review! I really enjoyed reading it! Thanks!

  • Nice review, Newbie. I am glad you enjoyed the show.

  • Loved the recap. Very nice. :)

  • Thanks for the recap.
    Good observations and I appreciate you going with an open mind vs. your impressions from TV. 2 completely different things to me live vs. TV and/or TV vs. recordings; each is good in their own way.
    That with the fact they have basically practiced this show now dozen’s of times vs. once or twice makes a huge difference for some of the performers.

    by-the-way I believe they converted Men’s Bathrooms to Women’s just for the concert considering the attendance; mostly women.

  • newbie389 & 17 – Both of those surprise me big time! You sound like a seasoned pro both in your writing & opinions! Spot on girl :thumbup_tb:

    How great you went with your Mom & Dad again and S8 was the favorite concert for all of you, great stuff to hear.

    Your bathroom breaks cracked me up, urinals in a lady’s room, why the nerve of those peeps for doing that!!! Not a bit surprised at the comments that were going around :) Also enjoyed hearing your Dad’s fake-outs of past concerts – so typical of most men I’ve known! haha

    Just loved your recap newbie & am so happy you all had a great time, thanks for sharing and hang tight to the good memories of this year’s Cleveland concert!! :smile1_tb:

  • Thanks, newbie! I really enjoyed your review, and you’re a really good, expressive writer. I love reading reviews like yours that almost make me feel like I was there. It’s particularly interesting reading reviews from fans of anyone other than Kris or Adam because the focus changes from a competition between those two (which I’m really, really tired of!) to the merits of the individual performances. So glad you had such a great time and, since I’ll be going to my first-ever Idol concert on Wednesday, I’m really excited to hear that you think this one is the best so far.

  • Great recap!! I have to say that the younger posters are doing a super job with their recaps and you are one who is at the top of that list. Thank you for taking the time to write this recap. You did a wonderful job!!!

  • I’m happy you enjoyed Adam and Kris even though your favorite was Matt. We met Matt and he’s a real doll! I wish him the best of luck in his career! I was at the Cleveland concert too and had the best time! The crowd was awesome!

    The ladies room had urinals because it’s really a men’s’ room that they convert to Ladies when there are big crowds. :) Those lines were LONG!!

  • I agree with dhunken! You younger posters are doing a great job and I love reading your experiences. Such enthusiasm and so much fun. Thank you for writing it.

    I loved the parts about your dad getting the rundown of the season on the way to the concert. So cool how you go as a family. My parents would have never considered taking me to a concert (and dropping me off) in the ’80s when I was a teen, much less go with me. That’s a great family experience. I’m really glad you all enjoyed it.

    Yeah, and my vote is they convert a men’s room to a women’s room for certain events. I saw my first show at an arena that’s primarily for hockey and let me tell you, they DEFINITELY should have converted one of the men’s rooms. It was easily the worst line I’ve ever seen. I held it, but my friend went while I waited. I was about ready to send the fire department in after her ‘“ it took FOREVER. I finally gave up and went back to our seats, sure we had just missed each other because it couldn’t have possibly taken that long. Wrong, it did.

    Keep writing and sharing your experiences!

  • What a lovely family you’ve got there newbie389. A wonderful recap, funny and so very positive.

    I loved the little details about your dad, it made me all misty actually.

    Thank you so much for sharing your concert experience with us. I am so glad that you all enjoyed yourselves.

  • Thanks for your recap, it was excellent!

  • Thank u so muuuch I loved this

  • Thank you, for the detailed recap; I thought you did a great job.

    Appreciate that you were able to keep an open mind and had something nice to say about all the Idols…

  • Your recap made me smile. Although Im a bit older than you, I still watch Idol with my parents every Tuesday night….gotta love family traditions :)

  • by-the-way I believe they converted Men’s Bathrooms to Women’s just for the concert considering the attendance; mostly women.

    I don’t want to question your assumption, AnninSD, but I have to ask, how would they know the audience would be mostly women? They have no way of knowing that, based on ticket sales. So maybe they just assume that, for whatever reason, more women use the rest rooms at intermission, at large concerts?

    (At the Boston concert there was a long line for the ladies’ room but not for the mens’. The attendance in Boston wasn’t mostly women, though. It seemed pretty evenly mixed.)

    Really nice recap, newbie389. Thanks!

  • great recap, glad you had a good time :)
    it’s so nice you have such close ties with your parents, I am also very close with my daughter and I hope it will last :)
    thanks

  • I’m biased for anyone who compliments Adam so awesomesaucedly. So… I love you bb :)

  • I think your family tradition of going to the AI tour concert is……..something very special and wonderful memories for you all to share!! Thanks for such a fun read of
    a moment by you and your family!!
    I’m finding, a few peeps are finding, most of the idols are, definitely, better live. Many good reasons for that,not the least being, the atmosphere of utter excitment, the darkness with the bright lights and other production “WOWs”. What Michael said about standing up, and then telling anyone behind to stand too, if You’r blocking their view!!!LOL He did set the tone, eh!
    Matt is doing so great now and, of course, even non followers are blown away by the Adam and then lovely kris keeps us beguiled and then calmed to reality with Na Na Na and you almost feel a kinship with all in the room!
    You are so lucky to have a engaged family. So many today are so disengaged from each other and they don’t know what they are missing!!!
    Appears you all had a better than fine time. Yes!!!

    So do this again next year and we’ll be looking for your re-cap!!! Thanks Newbie389!!

  • Newbie 389: Nice job; you write very well and express yourself beautifully. Definitely captured the concert atmosphere and flavor.

  • I love the recaps, and appreciate people taking the time to write them up. Sounds like you had a great time!

  • Very well written recap. I felt like I was there with you. Great job and thanks for sharing your experience.

  • Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us! Great family outing – good memories.

    The lady behind me said to her daughter something like, ‘he could totally be standing outside Abercrombie and Fitch’  and her daughter- my age- was like ‘uh, he could totally be my husband!’  Haha i agree. Anyway, I’d buy his album. He impressed me

    Loved this comment. Yes, I can see both Megan and Anoop doing some modeling along the way. I am glad you liked his performance. Great recap!

Leave a Reply

You must login to post a comment.