Season 9 Preview: Justin Williams, Tyler Grady, Luke Edgemon
Not only is Hollywood week in progress (and we may be previewing people already cut), but this is the week Season 9 starts. Woo! For some of us, this season couldn’t start soon enough. It will be interesting to see who resonates tomorrow with the viewing public (some of the strongest fan bases develop during the audition rounds). Who will be prominently featured during the auditions only to crash and burn this week in Hollywood and still make the voting rounds? Correct me if I’m wrong, but this is the latest we’ve ever had the Hollywood rounds. Anyway, I’m sure that we are not the only ones that peruse a contestant’s body of work. I wouldn’t be the least bit surprised if the producers do the same and grant a pass to some people who look strong, but maybe have a bad week. Plus, they are casting a show to draw viewers. Anyway. If you have Hollywood spoilers, please post them somewhere at MJs (or the internet or twitter or on your blog and we’ll find them) or send them to MJ.
Yesterday, we examined some on the distaff side of the competition . Let’s look at those who might make up the other 12 contestants..
Usual Disclaimer: Remember, that the Hollywood round doesn’t occur until this week this year. We don’t know how far any of these contestants might go. And since we never see some of the competition round contestants until the competition starts, we might never see some of these people. We might have even found the wrong person with the same name.
Number 29: Justin Williams
Hometown: Mesa, Arizona
Age: 27
Instrument: Guitar, piano
Number 30: Tyler Grady
Hometown: Nazareth, Pennsylvania
Number 31: Luke Edgemon
Age: 21
Hometown: Fayetteville, NC
Pictures/Myspace/Links after the jump
Justin Williams
Picture 1 Picture 2
White Chocolate (youtube)
Apologize (youtube)
Fly Me to the Moon
You Are Loved
Please Don’t Leave Me (youtube)
The Prayer (youtube)
National Anthem (youtube) (the litmus test for all Idols ![]()
Youtube Channel
Introducing Justin – Hollywood Week
Some of you may remember Justin Williams from last season. He made it to the chair’s episode before getting cut. Justin didn’t get a lot of air time, but he was a member of the most buzz generating group of last year, White Chocolate (which also featured Matt and Kris). A lot of people wanted to hear more from him.
In the youtubes, Justin demonstrates an ability to do covers and some pretty smooth vocals. He’s already got some fans from last year (and may pick up some from Matt and Kris). He’s a little different than the other WBWG. He’s a little less alternative and a little more AC which might help him stand out in a crowded field. He’s got a killer backstory. He survived cancer at 18 (but will Idol chose to show that with another cancer survivor amongst the Hollywood bound?). Plus, he’ll have the experience with Hollywood so that might help him avoid crumbling and stumbling (he certainly knows how to pick a group to do a group number with). It also looks like he’s been busy the last year generating an internet footprint for his music which shows dedication. He could make the show to add a little contrast. Plus, he’s not bad looking.
Tyler Grady
Picture 1 Picture 2 Picture 3
Band’s Myspace
Band’s Facebook
Band’s EP
Well, here is one of the few male contestants who doesn’t apparently play a guitar. That could make him stand out. Plus, he doesn’t look emo/alternative rock. So, another plus for not getting lost in the crowd. He’s got a good textured voice and his rock band has some decent tracks on Myspace (all the youtube videos for this band have been deleted). But, can he do covers? What will he do with Broadway and Latin week? How does he do without the band? He could get cast to add some mix and he’ll probably gain a dedicated fan base if he does.
Luke Edgemon
My Word
Back at One (youtube)
Halo
Umbrella (youtube)
Youtube Channel
This dude is generating a lot of buzz on some of the Idol fan boards. I’m going to get burned in effigy for the first time in Season 9 by saying that I don’t get it. Dude has an alright voice and he’s not ugly, but he totally lacks any musical sense. He often over-sings to the point of shoutiness. He doesn’t seem to realize what his range is and sometimes picks songs that are outside of it on both the bottom and the top. I’m hearing a lot of “Dawg, I don’t know. That was kind of pitchy for me.” in his future. He manages in Halo to be both flat and sharp. Wow. Plus, some of the songs he picks do a terrible job of featuring his voice such at is. Just because a song is popular and you like it, doesn’t mean you should sing it. There are certain songs that just don’t work for certain people (unless you can re-arrange them and he shows no evidence of the ability to do so). His phrasing sucks too. Bring on the fire-ants. I have a Costco-sized can of RAID at the ready.
Thanks Idol Maniac and Sassycatz for the tips on Tyler and Justin.
If you’ve missed some of the Idol Hopefuls for Season 9, checkout the Season 9 Preview Roundup.

Wow….just wow, really nice soft vocals, and then he blew me away with the prayer.
I don’t know why this guy did not make it last season?????
Ok…..Go Justin. You need to get trough hollywood week please!!
Justin Williams: wow, really like his recorded voice on “Please Don’t Leave Me.” Expressive. We’ll see if he has the live chops.
Tyler Grady: has that sort of Strokes husky vibe to his voice that works well for actual current rock. Like you, not sure if it can work on a covers show.
justjude, the story with this guy is actually very interesting. I saw a promo for the season 9 a couple of weeks ago with Justin singing a short clip of “I am feeling good” and I was very intrigued. I actually posted a question here at MJ if anyone knew who this guy was, so someone gave me a name and I actually googled him and this is what I found:
http://ktimothy.com/American-Idol/2008/12/07/justin-williams-eliminated-because-of-my-blog/
He is kind of interesting, I definately want to see more of him.
Just to make it more clear, and I saw it on some other site, Justin family apparently leaked that he made it to a certain point in the competition and he was kicked out.
Yay it’s season 9 week!!!! (although I will admit to loving some White Chocolate!). I like both of these guys (Justin and Tyler). I’m very interested in watching the Boston auditions to see some of those Berklee kids
Well, I’ll feel like crap if I just got 31 people eliminated (though, between me VFTW, Idol360, Idol Chatter, Idol Forums, etc) we’ve probably eliminated the entire set of Hollywood bound contestants.
Good luck Hollywood Bound people!
Justin: I remember Justin. He wasn’t one of my favorites. I watched the videos MJ put up and I’m still not interested. He always sounds like he is losing his voice when he sings and is boring. He is hot tho.
Tyler: No.
Luke: No.
Woah! That is weird. I never heard anything like that before.
Justin: He seems decent, but not as great as many of the others. He might have a shot, but I’d need to hear more guys.
Tyler: Lack of versatility may hurt, but he does give Idol something. However, Daniel Murillo does so more. Not sure about him.
Luke: Totally agreed. Do not like him. I’d cut him at the first opportunity.
Idol Chatter just profiled Michelle Delamor. She HAS to make it.
Kirsten, I tried to make it more clear by editing my post, but want to try again. The blogger had nothing to do with Justin elimination, I posted the link because thats where I found the story at first, but then I saw other info that some relatives who knew that Justin got through to a certain point, leaked it on the web. But I learned it from the posts that other relatives left on the blogger site, accusing her which is total bs.
I like Tyler and his band a lot. No idea how well he would do on the show, but I would buy their stuff tomorrow if I could.
Michelle was featured a two part Idol commercials and we discussed her a bit here.
Is Luke Edgemon a Digimon or something? His last name brings back childhood memories. Other than that, meh. I like the genre of My Word, but even that song bored me.
Also, I’m remembering Justin Williams in the I Want You Back performance. His voice was the weakest of the 4, I think he needed the other 3 to carry him (but omg that performance was still soooo amazing).
Tyler Grady: O_O. He looks and sounds so lost, chronologically speaking. Not terrible, but he looks mind-blowingly born in the wrong era. Could be interesting to see how far he goes, he has a somewhat interesting style. Or, you know, maybe with the less dull colors and dress of those photos >_>.
I’m not really wowed with these guys, but Justin probably has the most potential.
OK, I like Michelle A LOT! She has something of both Kelly and Leona Lewis in her, really nice voice and seems comfortable on the stage, I hope she goes far.
Luke is very good. His cover is Hackensack is very good, which sold me
. Is it just me, or am I the only one who thought Justin did well on the white chocolate performance? Kinda preferred him to Kris, who is my 2nd favorite from S8.
The audition part is my favorite of all.
Ususally during audition is when I pick my favorite and on Hollywood week is when I make my final choise base on who impress me more.
Looking foward to this season starts. I want a girl this season, need more girls in my Ipod
Justin is going to go far! He sings ala Il Divo. I couldn’t understand why he didn’t go further last year instead of someone like Norm.
Uhoh on the cancer pity story! That’s going to cause some headaches on the web.