The Songs of Michael Jackson: What Should the Idols Sing?


Michael Jackson is on some sort of a comeback.   Not only will his songs be featured on American Idol this week, but he’s just announced a 10 concert stint in London this summer.   There are also hints he’ll be following the London shows with a world tour.

As I listen to his songs performed on the Idol stage this week, I’ll try to remember what a great artist he was rather than focus on the pitiful trainwreck he’s become.   To be honest, I predict canceled performances and major dramz before Jackson makes it through those 10 London performances. Sads.

Jackson was a big part of my young life, so I’ll just enjoy the music.

Typically, I’d be brimming   with ideas about what I think the Idols should sing.   But thanks to this year’s crappy semi-final format that had most of the kids performing only once–sometimes badly–on the Idol stage, I have more questions, than suggestions.

I wonder if Adam Lambert will moonwalk?   Will Anoop Desai bust out some new dance moves? Which inspirational MJ song will Danny Gokey sing? What the hell is Megan Corkrey going to sing? Does Kris Allen wish he’d saved “Man in the Mirror” for the finals?

And, what will Paula say to the contestant who chooses “Rock with You”?

Calling his choice the “kiss of death,” Paula chastised Stephen Fowler for choosing “Rock With You” during the week 1 semi-final round,   insisting it belonged to only one artist. “And that artist is Michael Jackson,” she said.

Paula makes a good point. I expect the kids to run to the relative safety of   the Jackson 5 and 70s era solo songs if possible.   Jackson’s later output is not easy to perform, or re-arrange (Chris Cornel and David Cook, notwithstanding).

What about a Michael Jackson theme week?   Who should sing what?   Will there be some spectacular trainwrecks, or do you think the kids will be alright?   Share your thoughts in comments!

Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Blogplay
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon

199 Responses to “The Songs of Michael Jackson: What Should the Idols Sing?”

  • madmike2276:

    If someone sings à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Screamà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  (Michael and Janet Jackson duet), I will vote for the first and possibly only time this season, no matter how terrible it is.

    That should be the group song, it would be awesome(ly) funny!

  • metsin6:

    Adam should definitely do Dirty Diana and Megan should do Can’t Help It

  • annoula:

    Again, seriously, I think somebody should do “Earth Song”…I don’t know why I remember it but I do…and except for the fact that the refrain is “Ahhhh” and “Ooohhhhh,” I like the melody and the ending.

  • annoula:

    If someone sings à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Screamà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  (Michael and Janet Jackson duet), I will vote for the first and possibly only time this season, no matter how terrible it is.

    Ooooh I love “Scream!!!” Adam should do this.

  • Valentin432:

    There is a cover of Human Nature that I really like:

    I could see Matt or maybee Kris with the guitar?

  • Victoria:

    Ooooh I love à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Scream!!!à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  Adam should do this.

    Yeah, I thought so too :)

  • tarheelgirl:

    Someone asked if the UNC Clef Hangers (Anoop’s a Capella group) had arranged any Michael Jackson songs, so I looked through their old CDs and found that they arranged Billie Jean for their 2001 Elevation CD. But, I doubt Anoop will choose that song. (http://www.clefhangers.com/albums.asp)

    Also, I saw that Ne-Yo has done Lady in My Life. And since Anoop is such a huge Ne-Yo fan, he might be more inclined to perform that song.

  • Joanna S.:

    Also, I saw that Ne-Yo has done Lady in My Life. And since Anoop is such a huge Ne-Yo fan, he might be more inclined to perform that song.

    If he does, he’s really going to need to change it up in a way that will really show off his range and vocal abilities. Ne-Yo’s version of that song is kinda boring.

  • pj:

    Yeah, a male singing a ballad on MJ week is going to be considered too derivative. They need to switch it up. I’m not sure that Scott or Jorge have anything but ballads in them. I hope they change my mind.

  • adamandeva:

    Broke out my Michael Jackson Number 1 Hits CD to take a refresher course. Now that I think about it, I would love Adam to sing “They Don’t Really Care About Us”. Just for the sheer drama of that song (one of my fav songs). Gah…seriously that was one of Michael’s brilliant songs! And it was one of the first pop songs to use that synthesized sound effect in the song background. Y’know the one that EVERY pop star uses now. I know that song probably won’t be on the approved list because it is soooo controversial.

    I think the producers know that Adam is gonna nail any MJ song this week. Look for him close to the end of the order of performances again this week…

    I am very excited for this theme as I have been a diehard fan of MJ’s music since I was a child. So sad he is such a mess now.

    P.S. Michael Sarver or Jasmine Murray should sing “You Can’t Win” by Michael from The Wiz soundtrack. Just for the sheer irony… :P

  • lovegoodmusic:

    Even though I prefer to hear up beat MJ songs tomorrow, I would like Alexis to sing and use her guitar.

  • cookcricket:

    The problem here is Danny using the fact that his wife died to get sympathy votes. However, it has been a while since weà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢ve seen Danny, so he might tone things down this week. I hope not, though.

    Hmmm, my verdict is still out on Danny. I don’t think that he has denied that this has brought him some attention and made people decide to listen to him. However, I just guessing (since I don’t know him) that he’s probably counting on the American people to listen to his vocals. Sadly many won’t simply because because of this.

    Many others have had extra attention brought to them for various reasons as well which is why Kris Allen doesn’t stand out and why so many count on him failing.

  • shy215:

    I am with u on this 1 mj I love the 79′-91 michael jackson and i hate plastic surgeons this might be a disaster becuz michaels voice has always been unique and there is no else like em’ and its gonna be hard for them becuz of all the various things mj does with his voice plus people often forget that mj had his songs written especially for him…this is gonna be tough i wonder if someone does earth song, stranger in moscow or human nature I love those particular songs becuz they all describe scenarios in human condition according to feelings and actions from a psychological level and I took that for a year so i love stuff like dat.

  • Victoria:

    Adamandeva, I agree that Adam would do great on “They Donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t Really Care About Us.” It’s a shame that song was misinterpretted and deemed controversial.

  • Michael Slezak’s new Idolatry: Top 13 Preview video is up at EW.

  • Grammie Kari:

    Too bad some of the girls canà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t do Janet. Or can they?

    I imagine they could if Michael wrote songs for his sister. I really don’t know. I think we may have some surprises of success from the girls. I also think Adam will do just fine regardless his choice. I just want to hear something spectacular!

  • bean99:

    I laughed at the Idolatry preview. I have to agree with them on Adam although I’m not sure I’d call him “skeezy”, lol.

  • sr4mjc:

    They’ve got Adam so totally wrong, I hope they change their mind when he nails a beautiful ballad.

  • tarheelgirl:

    According to the second hand song site, LL Cool J and Boyz II Men have sampled (I’m not sure exactly what that means) Lady in My Life (in their song Hey Lover), which further leads me to believe that Anoop will choose it. Hopefully, he’ll change the song up if he does sing it!

  • weareallinnocent:

    Yeah, I’m a big fan of Slezak, but I’m totally not with him on his views of Adam — at least those voiced in the video. He’s curiously less critical in the photo gallery reviews and suggestions though, most likely hedging his bets lol.

  • Sometimes, Slezak and I see eye to eye. This is one of those times.

  • Natasha:

    Slezak really dislikes Adam so I’ve had to cross him off my list this season. Cross Slezak off my list that is, not Adam. Lol.

    Anyway, I’m looking forward to a reliable spoiler list because I’m genuinely curious about what everyone has come up with. Lots of good suggestions in this thread.

  • Victoria:

    Tarheelgirl, sampling means an artist uses part of a song in their own original song. And I think you’re right; it’s a good bet Anoop sings that.

    I like Slezak, but I disagree with him about Adam. I will still be watching Idolatry though, and his recaps are too witty to pass up. :) I just hope he changes his mind about Adam.

    I’m waiting for a REAL spoiler list… anyone????

    TMZ might have one. I hate going over there because they are rude and sleezy, and I don’t want to give their website any hits, haha. Plus it takes forever to load.

  • kbr:

    Ok so I love me some old MJ…do we know if Jackson 5 is allowed? This is my wish list tonight…. or for those I am not a big fan of what I think they will sing:

    Alexis: It’s Your Thing (Jackson 5)- want to sing
    Anoop: The Way You Make Me Feel – want to sing
    Danny: I’ll be There (Jackson 5) – will sing
    Allison: Leave Me Alone – want to sing
    Adam: Dirty Diana – want to sing
    Kris: Say, Say, Say (duet with Paul McCartney) – want to sing
    Lil Rounds: Remember the Time – want to sing
    Matt G: Smooth Criminal – want to sing
    Scott: Will You Be There – want to sing
    Jorge: Heal the World – will sing
    Megan: Rock with You – want to sing
    Jasmine: I want You Back (Jackson 5) – will sing
    Michael: I have no idea…good luck!

    Only a crazy person would sing Billie Jean…but I guess you never know!

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Got a tip? A Question? A Complaint? Contact Me Here: Contact Me

Follow mjsbigblog on Twitter

Ready to post a comment? Read my Guidelines first:
Posting Guidelines

Archives
March 2010
S M T W T F S
« Feb    
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031