Top 24 SPOILER ALERT! They aren’t even trying to hide it–Or is it some kind of nutty ruse?

Thanks to Jennifer for sending this along to me. From the Pasadena Star-News:

PASADENA - A cloak of secrecy hung over the filming of an “American Idol” segment on the rainy steps of City Hall early Tuesday morning.

About 16 of the talent-show contestants - no one from Fox television would say exactly how many - were filmed emerging from their cars and going up City Hall’s steps. No one would say why.

“I can confirm that we are shooting today, but details are confidential,” Fox publicist Jill Hudson said in an e-mail sent several hours after the 7 a.m. City Hall shoot.

Ariel Penn, who heads the city’s film office, said she believed the Fox show might have used City Hall as a substitute for the Civic Auditorium. Normally, Penn said, the finalists audition in the auditorium’s Gold Room and are filmed going up the steps outside.

CHECK OUT THE PICTURES! I’ll try to get some of them up…

ETA: Photos after the JUMP!

Related Posts

Top 11 Spoilers!
Elliott Yamin Interview in the National Ledger
David Hernandez - Exit Interviews
Bits and Pieces
More Season 6 News

75 Responses to “Top 24 SPOILER ALERT! They aren't even trying to hide it--Or is it some kind of nutty ruse?”


Pages: « 1 [2] Show All

  1. 51 Grammie Kari Jan 23rd, 2008 at 7:52 pm

    Michael Johns is the only audition I didn’t see. Wish I could play YouTube video.

    MJ, I appreciate your efforts and look forward to the final word you have to say. Seems some lists don’t agree with others. Thanks!

  2. 52 Sarah Jan 23rd, 2008 at 7:55 pm

    I think I shall wait for those who excel at these kind of things to sort all this out. :)

    *crossing fingers that Drew makes it* I like good ol’ Southern boys. ;)

  3. 53 maracaibo Jan 23rd, 2008 at 7:57 pm

    Colton was cut? Oh man! I thought he would be in for sure…
    What’s the deal with these spoilers? They change all the time. I don’t know what to believe now.

  4. 54 jersey Jan 23rd, 2008 at 7:59 pm

    I’m still going with Joe’s place and so far, she says Colton, Drew, Cardin - all cut. She said she will post more after 9. (when I last checked at 7)

  5. 55 Lisa Jan 23rd, 2008 at 8:01 pm

    I have no idea. The list is pretty bumming right now. I am just reading the list from MJ’s link to IDF. There are 3 people there who are supposedly the ones who know and all three saying those folks are out. (still that is why I said rumors) Jersey that is one I was referring to also.

    Season 7, the year of the tweens ugh.

  6. 56 jobbix Jan 23rd, 2008 at 8:39 pm

    Obviously some of the sources are screwing with them..LOL That’s why the lists don’t match. Hopefully JoesPlace will straighten them out soon.

  7. 57 t2 Jan 23rd, 2008 at 8:53 pm

    Neon —

    From Rickey.org

    Kristy Lee Cook — Sexy Pics Emerge from the Bowels of the Internets

    NOW, the competition has begun, LOL!!!

    BWAH!!!

  8. 58 Sarah Jan 23rd, 2008 at 8:56 pm

    I’m scouring myspaces for *any* hints…

    Cardin and Drew both have comments posted in the last 24 hours leaning toward the positives from people who seem to be old friends from back home…

  9. 59 primeminister Jan 23rd, 2008 at 9:04 pm

    Sarah– Colton too.

  10. 60 mj Jan 23rd, 2008 at 9:07 pm

    Obviously some of the sources are screwing with them..LOL That’s why the lists don’t match. Hopefully JoesPlace will straighten them out soon.

    I think this article–the pictures and video–may have been planted by the show. I would not be surprised if there was a huge disinformation campaign going on right now to throw people off the track.

  11. 61 jobbix Jan 23rd, 2008 at 10:21 pm

    Wow!! Looks like KLC had too many skeletons in her closet. I wonder how TPTB will deal with this controversy if they turn out to be true. Many powerful forces are waiting to jump on AI for this, if you know what I mean..LOL

  12. 62 beesims Jan 23rd, 2008 at 10:28 pm

    Sarah– Colton too.Sarah

    Please don’t tell me they got rid of Colton (AKA “Cody”—Beesims’ early prediction of male country singer Season 7 winner)!!!!

    Actually, when I finally did see Colton sing, I was disturbed by the hair and beetle brows.

    I think MJ is right that that photo shoot is part of planned disinformation campaign. Something was very fishy about the whole thing.

  13. 63 milajoy Jan 24th, 2008 at 1:48 am

    MJ, I posted the top 24 on my blog

    http://idolforums.com/index.php?automodule=blog&req=showblog&blogid=938&st=

    Im missing two girls, but should know them soon.

    Its, um, not a pretty picure

  14. 64 milajoy Jan 24th, 2008 at 1:56 am

    All the details are on my blog at:

    http://idolforums.com/index.php?automodule…gid=938&st=

    But, for better or worse:

    Guys:

    1. Chikeze Eze
    2. Colton - a 16 year old guy
    3. Danny Noriega
    4. David Archuleta
    5.David Cook
    6. David Hernandez
    7. Garrett Haley
    8. Jason Castro
    9. Jason Yeager
    10. Luke Menard
    11. Michael Lee Johns
    12. Robbie Carrico

    Girls:

    1. Alania Whitaker
    2. Alex Lushington
    3. Amanda Overmyer
    4. Amy Davis
    5. Brooke White
    6. Carly Smithson
    7. Kady Malloy
    8. Kristie Lee Cook
    9. Ramiele Maulbay
    10. Syesha Mercado

    I will probably be able to get the final two tomorrow. However I am certain that the follwoing contestants were cut:

    Drew
    Colton Swon
    Cardin
    Brandon
    Lorena
    Lisa Aukerman
    Buck
    Mia
    Kyle
    Rosie
    Shaun Barrowes
    Josiah Leming
    Marsha Hancock
    Adele Michelle
    Aaron Saunders
    Neyshia
    Jordan Minter

    MICHAEL SANFILIPPO was not part of the top 50 - neiter was JOHN EDWARD CAREY

    The only two girls that I have no idea - yet - if they are in or out are:

    Asiah
    Joanne B.

    Unless theres a girl or two that we dont know about - which is completely probable - then they would fill up the top 12

    This is 100% guys. Not a list I’m happy with at all, but It is for sure. I havent steered you wrong yet…

  15. 65 milajoy Jan 24th, 2008 at 1:58 am

    Oh, that video was filemed BEFORE the top 24 was chosen. Its showing the top 50 having “fun” in los angeles.

  16. 66 vixen Jan 24th, 2008 at 2:59 am

    if that’s right, i’m really disappointed - everyone i was interested in was cut. :(

  17. 67 purplesmile Jan 24th, 2008 at 3:08 am

    Three Davids and two Jasons in the competition…interesting. And the Colton there is not the Swon one? The name Chikeze Eze intrigues me.

    Why am I sad that Cardin is not there even though I have not seen or heard her on AI yet? :s And the Filipino-American girl, Ramiele, apparently made it? She must have sung better than she sounded on her myspace because based on just that, I didn’t think she sounded like somebody who could make it to the show. Well, good luck to her. If she is indeed a better singer than I initially thought, I think I would already have a sentimental favorite for now. Heh. :)

  18. 68 t2 Jan 24th, 2008 at 7:11 am

    Uh oh! I only recognize maybe 4 names out of that whole list.

  19. 69 jersey Jan 24th, 2008 at 7:13 am

    Thank you Milajoy! I’ve been waiting for your update! I’m interested to see Jason Castro, and I do like Michael Johns. Boo on Colton Swon being cut.

  20. 70 Sarah Jan 24th, 2008 at 7:25 am

    Well if that list is right, they’ve pretty much caused me to lose most of my interest in this season. Good job, TPTB.

  21. 71 itsalleternal Jan 24th, 2008 at 8:44 am

    Yeah it looked so good coming in, and the elevator eats all the good people up (that we know of)? Of course, the list may not be right…and they may be amazing after all once we hear them (3 cities to go)…

  22. 72 itsalleternal Jan 24th, 2008 at 8:50 am

    Consensus top 24 (listed on ALL known sources, meaning they are those with the highest confidence, although I still wouldn’t say 100%): Carly, Alaina, Kristy, Kady, Michael J, David A, Danny.

    Everyone else has 1 or more source saying he/she was cut, so confidence should be seen as lower.

    Their accuracy was 100% last season, but they missed on Heather Cox and (I think) Stevie Scott in Season 5, perhaps one or two others.

  23. 73 mj Jan 24th, 2008 at 8:54 am

    Their accuracy was 100% last season, but they missed on Heather Cox and (I think) Stevie Scott in Season 5, perhaps one or two others.

    NOPE. The final spoiler list compiled in Season 5 was 100% correct. I should know. I compiled it. :).

  24. 74 Easy Jan 24th, 2008 at 12:47 pm

    Who’s the rocker looking dude in the front of those pics? Anybody know?

  25. 75 webmanpi Jan 27th, 2008 at 4:07 pm

    You can go buy Kristi Cooks album right now.

    She already has a record deal

    Sounds fishy

    check it out

    http://cdbaby.com/cd/kristylee

Pages: « 1 [2] Show All