The American Idol season 2018 finalists seemed pretty chummy while competing on the show and out on tour over the following summer. But currently? All is not well in season 16 land.
It all started when Cade Foehner, who finished 4th in the competition, tweeted a braggadocious post about the success of his wife, Gabby Barrett, who finished that season in 3rd place. Currently, the singer has a major label single, “I Hope” climbing up the country charts.
Except, that the tweet below is actually a replacement for a previous tweet that specifically boasted that Gabby would be the most successful Idol of season 16. In other words, more popular than even the winner of 2018, Maddie Poppe. Of course, rewording the tweet to say Gabby would be the most successful Idol ever is kind of the same thing? As you can imagine, fans of other Idols took issue with Cade’s boast
I am so happy for my Wife @gabbybarrett_ she has taken off since our season of American Idol! I do believe she is on her way to being the most successful one to ever be on the show! What an honor to support her and be her husband! Christ is very good to us and we’re undeserving. pic.twitter.com/kDIxXs14sd
— Cade Foehner (@CadeFoehner) February 11, 2020
Maddie, who is working her own single, “Not Losing You” to pop radio responded, “It’s sweet to be proud of your wife but you ain’t gotta take shots at everybody else from our season.” OOPS!
Congrats to her and happy for her success. It’s sweet to be proud of your wife but you ain’t gotta take shots at everybody else from our season. People who you call your friends? Pretty unnecessary. Serves absolutely no purpose but to piss everyone else off. Low blow dude.
— Maddie Poppe (@MaddiePoppe) February 11, 2020
Cade responded…but not with an apology!
Hey gang, i’m just proud of my wife. That’s all. Not trying to hurt anyone.
— Cade Foehner (@CadeFoehner) February 10, 2020
When fans stayed angry he deleted and reposted his original tweet. Of course, fans still stayed angry! “Apparently if you don’t POST your successes, you don’t have ANY. Sad,” Maddie wrote.
Apparently if you don’t POST your successes, you don’t have ANY. Sad.
— Maddie Poppe (@MaddiePoppe) February 11, 2020
….AND CADE STILL NOT APOLOGIZING. Fans continued to call him out.
On days when tweets are taken out of context and I’ve hurt folks unintentionally, I am reminded of the beauty of Christ’s Gospel. He suffered the death I deserved, and the wrath I should feel. What love would condescend so far as to save a wretched, pitiful man like me? Christ!
— Cade Foehner (@CadeFoehner) February 11, 2020
Dude, just say I am sorry, I was wrong! When you hurt someone you own it, and make amends, not excuses. That’s what Jesus tells us to do.
— poppe_tart (@poppe_tart) February 11, 2020
Eventually more Idols from Season 16 chimed in, including Ada Vox, Catie Turner and Maddie’s boyfriend, runner-up Caleb Lee Hutchinson.
*POPCORN GIF*
You know nothing & will continue to be ignorant to the truth becuase you have no access or information on anything other than what you’ve seen from the outside.
I promise you that your mind and tone would change drastically if you knew the truth. ?
— Stream “Tea Time” ??? (@AdaVox) February 11, 2020
What’s funny is all of the people defending the actions without actually knowing anything.
They don’t know the things we heard and saw firsthand.
They only see what television has allowed them to see & will continue to remain blind.— Stream “Tea Time” ??? (@AdaVox) February 11, 2020
It’s wonderful for a Star to quickly shine beautiful & bright, but that same star is also among the first to burn out. ?
— Stream “Tea Time” ??? (@AdaVox) February 11, 2020
Caleb joined in, but kept his reaction low key.
We just ain’t doing it the way everyone else is, so the path is different. You’re appreciate!
— Caleb Lee Hutchinson (@calebleemusic) February 11, 2020
And then season 5 winner TAYLOR HICKS enters the fray. This might be my favorite part!
Yea just to name a few ? https://t.co/3uNqZkXUvw
— Taylor Hicks (@TaylorHicks) February 11, 2020
https://t.co/3vZQv7kPDR pic.twitter.com/FUq5ImwQrI
— Taylor Hicks (@TaylorHicks) February 11, 2020
And as for Gabby herself? She stayed cool and above the fray. Of course, she’s probably the only one of the bunch with a social media advisor. Heh.
I love you. Thank you for your continuous support. I am very blessed! ?? https://t.co/z16kPx9vMu
— Gabby Barrett (@GabbyBarrett_) February 11, 2020
UPDATE: As it turns out, while Gabby lays low, she’s got surrogates doing her dirty work. Get a load of what her father posted on Facebook. “Super proud of my son-in-law! It’s funny how the snowflakes come out of the woodwork pissing and moaning. Once again they don’t like facts. Typical liberals telling him “ It wasn’t cool dude.” They were NEVER Your friends!!! They stab both of you in the back constantly. But don’t put it on social media so they can show how “sweet” they are. They are Perfect for Hollyweird. ” Typical maga behaving like an a**h***. His Facebook is a dumpster fire.
UPDATE: Gabby’s father deleted or changed the privacy setting on his Facebook post. Thank Jesus for screen grab! Hallelujah!
Maddie and Catie respond to Gabby’s father. Catie eventually deleted her tweet.
We’re not “friends” apparently. U dumb snowflake.
— Maddie Poppe (@MaddiePoppe) February 11, 2020
Gabby’s father’s brand new Facebook post. Why delete the first post? Just who is the SNOWFLAKE here? The projection rolling off these posts is really….something. SAD.
AND WHAT THE ACTUAL EFF? Something is seriously wrong with this man.
Look at this guyyyyyy.
Talk about embarrassing… #BOOM ??He is the exact reason people box in republicans and “Christians” as bad people.
I’m honestly so sorry for Gabby dealing with this. pic.twitter.com/blzukHjiXX— Stream “Tea Time” ??? (@AdaVox) February 12, 2020
Ada posted another one. Gabby’s Dad just cannot let it go. CRAY CRAY
Wonderful. Another video from @GabbyBarrett_ ‘s dad! Bashing “snowflakes”, now being transphobic, & continuing to shove “God” and politics in people’s faces.
This behavior is revolting.
Is this really what companies like @Disney and Warner brothers want around them? pic.twitter.com/EjBiMMxGx6— Stream “Tea Time” ??? (@AdaVox) February 12, 2020
I mean, who is really the “broken” one here? Hint: It’s not Maddie.
Never thought I’d be cyber bullied by a 50-year-old man…but here we are…almost two years later…STILL HAPPENING.
— Maddie Poppe (@MaddiePoppe) February 12, 2020